Naturalizer Everly Pump

Price Range: $$

At Nordstrom:
Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars – 160 ratings
Includes a couple 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoe looked great, was super comfortable, and had a fantastic fit, a narrow heel, and a narrow and well shaped toe.
Also includes a couple reviews from narrow buyers who said the narrow width was not narrow enough. One of the reviewers said the narrow width was too wide in the instep, and the other mentioned the heel cup.
View shoe on Nordstrom site

At Macy’s:
Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars – 177 ratings
Includes a 5 star review from a narrow buyer who said the shoes were so comfortable.
Also includes a couple reviews from narrow buyers who said the narrow width was not narrow enough. One of the reviewers said the narrow width was too wide in the instep, and the other mentioned the heel cup.
View shoe on Macy’s site

At Zappos.com:
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars – 197 ratings
Includes a few 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoe was super cute, comfortable, and secure but not tight. One of the reviewers went down a 1/2 size to get a good fit.
Includes a 4 star review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width was somewhat wide, especially in the heel. The reviewer decided to keep the shoes and put heel grips in the heels.
Also includes a few reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes were lovely, but the narrow width was not narrow enough. One of the reviewers said the narrow width was too wide in the instep, and another mentioned the heel cup.
View shoe on Zappos site