Trotters Sugar Mary Jane Flat

Price Range: $$

At Zappos.com:
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars – 107 ratings
Includes a few 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes are cute and fit perfectly, can be worn comfortably for 8 hours right out of the box, and the straps help keep the shoes on narrow feet.
Also includes a couple reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes are nice and made of soft leather, but the heels slipped even in the narrow width; a review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width fits true to size, but the reviewer would prefer them to have a 1 inch heel; and a review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width was not narrow enough.
View shoe on Zappos site

At Nordstrom:
Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars – 44 ratings
Includes a couple 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who liked that the shoes fit well, are true to length and width, are comfortable right out of the box, pack well (not stiff or bulky), have a strap that keeps the sides from gaping, and can look dressy or casual.
View shoe on Nordstrom site

At Macy’s:
Rating: Not rated
View shoe on Macy’s site