Naturalizer Darry Lug Sole Loafer

Price Range: $$

At Zappos.com:
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars – 391 ratings
Includes a couple 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes fit perfect, were very comfortable and stylish, and had just enough heel for longer jeans.
Also includes a couple 4 star reviews from narrow buyers, one of whom said the shoes were a tad wide but the reviewer could deal with it, and the other who loved the loafers but was adding pads to try and tighten how the heels fit.
A few narrow buyers gave 3 star reviews – one reviewer said the shoes were cute but ran short, and the others liked the appearance of the shoes but said the heel slipped horribly.
Several reviews mention the shoe having a narrow toe box, but a wide heel.
View shoe on Zappos site

At Nordstrom:
Rating: 3.9 out of 5 stars – 308 ratings
Includes a couple 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes fit perfect, were very comfortable and stylish, and had just enough heel for longer jeans.
Includes a few 4 star reviews from narrow buyers, one of whom said the narrow width was a tad too wide but the reviewer could deal with it, and a couple others who said the heels were a bit too big but hoped that would improve as the the shoe was broken in and the leather softened, or by adding pads.
Also includes a review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width just wasn’t narrow enough – more like a slightly narrow B width.
View shoe on Nordstrom site