Naturalizer Vera Ankle Strap Sandal

Price Range: $$

At Zappos.com:
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars – 691 ratings
Includes several 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the sandals were beautiful, comfortable, and fit very well.
Includes a 4 star review from a buyer with narrow feet(width purchased not specified) who said the shoes were easy to walk in, but after a while, the reviewer wished they had more cushion in the footbed.
Also includes a couple reviews that said the narrow width was not narrow enough; a couple reviews from narrow buyers who needed medium width in this shoe; a review from a narrow buyer who said the toe strap material caused blisters after 2 hours of wear; and a review from a narrow buyer who said the shoes were comfortable and fit well, but the ankle strap ripped off the heel cup.
Many reviews mention the shoe running narrow.
View shoe on Zappos site

At Nordstrom:
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars – 6 ratings
View shoe on Nordstrom site

At Macy’s:
Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars – 490 ratings
Includes many 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who said the shoes were lovely, nicely padded, comfortable, easy to walk in, and fit perfectly.
Includes a 5 star review from a buyer who purchases narrow width shoes when available, but said the medium width in this shoe was a perfect fit.
Also includes a review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width was too narrow and recommended ordering the medium width, and a review from a narrow buyer who said the narrow width was not narrow enough (the strap across the foot).
Many reviews mention the shoe running narrow.
View shoe on Macy’s site