Trotters Fayth Loafer

Price Range: $

At Nordstrom:
Rating: 3 out of 5 stars – 19 ratings
Includes a couple 5 star reviews from narrow buyers, one who said the shoe fit perfectly in the reviewer’s usual size, and the other who said the narrow width fit perfectly, but the shoe ran a full size small.
Also includes a review from a narrow buyer who said the shoe ran at least a 1/2 size small, and the heel was too loose even in the narrow width.
Another review from a narrow buyer also said the heel was not consistent with a narrow width, but rated the shoe as running slightly large.
View shoe on Nordstrom site

At Macy’s:
Rating: 3.3 out of 5 stars – 3 ratings
Includes a 3 star review from a narrow buyer for whom the shoes did not fit when the reviewer replaced the cushioned inserts that come with the shoe with the reviewer’s own orthotic. The reviewer said the shoes are worth narrow buyers giving a try since the thick, cushioned insert does make the shoe feel snug, but also said the shoes themselves don’t offer the kind of narrow fit and support that you may expect from a shoe that is specifically cut for a narrow foot.
View shoe on Macy’s site