Vionic Alameda Mary Jane Flat

Price Range: $$

At Macy’s:
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars – 138 ratings
Includes several 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who love the shoes and said they are on trend, great quality, fit perfectly, are very comfortable, and have arch support and an adjustable strap that helps keep heels in place. A couple of these reviewers recommended sizing down a 1/2 size.
A few other reviews (not from narrow buyers) mention the back of the shoe causing blisters and bleeding on heels.
View shoe on Macy’s site

At Zappos:
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars – 78 ratings
Includes a few 5 star reviews from narrow buyers who loved the fit, style and arch support of the shoes. One of these reviewers went down a 1/2 size in this shoe.
Also includes a few 5 star reviews from buyers with narrow feet (width purchased not specified) who said the shoes were beautiful, comfortable, had amazing insole support, and fit perfectly.
View shoe on Zappos site